precode wrote:I have to disagree with the contention that A&C are no longer funny. I introduced WHO DONE IT? last Saturday at the TCM Festival to a packed house--almost all of whom had never seen it--and despite the ungodly hour (9:AM) they were howling throughout and cheered wildly at the end. They made a lot of new fans that day.
Mike S.
"So she has a couple of buck teeth."
"I don't care how much they cost."
Mike, no arguments from me on WHO DONE IT? -- definitely the best of the pre-46 A &Cs. Very little romantic subplot or extraneous numbers, and no last-reel phony rear-screen chase finale. William Bendix is one of the best foils for Costello - a dopey guy who's also a perfect menace. Best version of the handcuff routine is found here.
Overall I personally prefer the boys ten years later on the A&C Show, when Bud's confidence man is allowed to be funny, too. Plus Sid Fields is just brilliant as the landlord...the best decision Bud & Lou ever made was to make him part of the show's regulars.