sethb wrote:I suppose I can understand why video companies issue their products in region-encoded releases. But why would they also have different versions of the same product in different regions (such as omitting IF I HAD A MILLION from the US issue) ? Is it a matter of territorial rights to the various films, as is the case with much of the Hal Roach catalog?
I used to have a 16mm one-reel Castle Films clip of the Fields/Skipworth vignette in IF I HAD A MILLION, so I know it has been previously released in the US. I also thought it was absolutely hilarious, too bad that it's not available in its country of origin! SETH
It's really more than just a different version; it's one BIG box of Fields films in the UK as opposed to 2 small boxes in the US. There are quite a few titles in the UK box that aren't in the US sets, although a few were later released as stand-alone titles here. Same thing with a BIG Dietrich box in the UK, while we got a micro-collection in the US.
Why, you ask? Who knows....for whatever reason, Universal's marketing department thought that nice big boxes would sell better in the UK than in the US. I have no idea whether that's true, but it all amounts to part of the reason that a multi-region player is essential. (Notwithstanding those folks who are bothered by the 4% PAL speedup; I don't notice it myself.) Ironically, IF I HAD A MILLION was in the first batch of laserdiscs that Universal released around 1979.